How much does a train ticket from New York City to Indianapolis cost?

The average train ticket price from New York City to Indianapolis is $149. The best way to find train tickets from New York City to Indianapolis is to book your tickets as early as possible. Prices tend to rise as your travel date approaches, so book in advance to secure the best prices!

How long is the train trip from New York City to Indianapolis?

A train trip between New York City and Indianapolis is around 22h 35m, although the fastest train will take about 22h 35m. This is the time it takes to travel the 643 miles that separates the two cities.

How many daily trains are there between New York City and Indianapolis?

The number of trains from New York City to Indianapolis can differ depending on the day of the week. On average, there are 2. Some trains are direct while others have layovers. Simplify your train trip from New York City to Indianapolis by comparing and selecting the train that fits your travel style and budget on Busbud.

Which train companies travel from New York City to Indianapolis?

When taking the train from New York City to Indianapolis, you can travel comfortably and safely with Amtrak.

Train New York City to Indianapolis from $105 | Refundable Tickets

Previously seen trips

Next departures for New York City to Indianapolis on November 20
Vehicle type	Departure time	Departure location	Trip duration	Arrival time	Arrival location	Recommended
Train	6:45am	Penn Station, Moynihan Train Hall	22h 30m	5:15am	Greyhound Amtrak Station	No tags
Train	6:40am	Penn Station, Moynihan Train Hall	22h 35m	5:15am	Greyhound Amtrak Station	No tags
Train	6:40am	Penn Station, Moynihan Train Hall	22h 35m	5:15am	Greyhound Amtrak Station	No tags
Train	6:40am	Penn Station, Moynihan Train Hall	22h 35m	5:15am	Greyhound Amtrak Station	No tags
Train	6:40am	Penn Station, Moynihan Train Hall	22h 35m	5:15am	Greyhound Amtrak Station	No tags

Compare 2 ways to go from New York City to Indianapolis

We recommend taking the bus

Among the sustainable travel choices, the bus stands out as the good way to reach Indianapolis. The journey takes about 21 hours 25 minutes and with fares starting at just $87, it presents an excellent value for a comfortable ride.

44bus per day

21h 25mAverage Duration

646 milesDistance

26kgCO₂ emissions

	Average Price	Average Duration	CO₂ emissions	Actions
Bus	Average Price$87 - $412	Average Duration21h 25m	CO₂ emissions 26kg CO₂e
Train	Average Price$110 - $1,338	Average Duration22h 35m	CO₂ emissions 94kg CO₂e

Where are the popular train stations and stops in New York City and Indianapolis?

New York City

A
Penn Station
254 W 31st St, New York, NY 10001, USA

Indianapolis

A
Greyhound Amtrak Station
350 S Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN 46225
Visit page

Train Companies

Amtrak

4/55,597 reviews

Staff4.7

Timeliness3.8

Cleanliness4.6

Wifi3.6

Based on 5597 reviews, the company was rated 4.1 stars on Busbud. Travelers were especially satisfied with the seats and the ticket access but often complained with the wifi. Amtrak ticket prices on this trip start at $110

Train and bus companies in US:Amtrak, Trenitalia, Renfe, VIA Rail Canada, Amtrak Acela, NS Nederlandse Spoorwegen, Iryo

Frequently asked questions about traveling from New York City to Indianapolis by train

How much does a train ticket from New York City to Indianapolis cost?
How long is the train trip from New York City to Indianapolis?
How many daily trains are there between New York City and Indianapolis?
Which train companies travel from New York City to Indianapolis?

Find cheapest prices for trains

Price is for a one-way ticket for one passenger and based on past searches.

Best price found

11/18

No data

11/19

$306

Today

No data

11/21

$251

11/22

No data

11/23

$306

11/24

No data

11/25

No data

The cheapest trip from New York City to Indianapolis was searched and found on Nov 21, 2025 with a price of $251

To save money and be sure you have the best seat, it's a good idea to buy your train tickets from New York City to Indianapolis, as early as possible.

You can expect to pay from $251 to $382 for a train ticket from New York City to Indianapolis based on the last 2 days. You can expect to find the cheapest price for the trip at $251 which is on 2025-11-21.